There are many movies that cover the subject about the abuse of the Catholic Church such as Spotlight and Doubt. We are Catholics... sons of God... not lawyers or politicians. Your journey seems have been far more direct than mine, which took place over perhaps 20 years. So to say this would be to affirm their error. No matter what your belief now, or if you have no belief at all. I remember when I was 19 and was hanging out with a lesbian friend of mine. I never had a problem being gay myself. It’s no secret the church is full of and ran by self-hating homosexual men. I got involved with Catholicism starting summer of 2017 when I was searching for something more spiritually. Everyday there are abuse scandals that are being revealed, yet the Church hasn’t done anything. It's the appeal-to-authority fallacy all over. | Getty Images . Catholic Christianity offers the world the fullness of the Christian Faith. The Catholic News Service recently told the story of Gabe Bouck, a seminarian in Washington, D.C., who lived most of his life as a Baptist. Thomism. No matter what your belief now, or if you have no belief at all. Wicket helps Cindel escape the evil witch Charal, and they befriend a hermit who may help them save the village. > **Note: This subreddit is a support forum and not a … You illustrate that that strategy would not work. edit subscriptions. Accused of sexually … I was an Atheist during my teens, but only recently have I been involved with the Church. How they handle abuse cases – another not-so-secret fact about the church is the amount of abuse church leaders have caused. I don't think that example would hold up since the State is currently wrong about natural marriage, just as they in cases of adulterous "remarriage". ", "Against the assault of laughter, nothing can stand." She was a follower of Scientology between 1979, when she joined at the age of nine alongside her parents, and 2013, when she left under acrimonious circumstances. However, I will not return to a Church that is hypocritical, contradictory with its teachings, judgmental and abusive. The Temple of Minerva in the town of Assisi, in Umbria, appears to be a perfectly preserved example of a Roman temple from the outside, but inside is home to a Catholic church.. -Mark Twain. I found a faith that focused on the individual's relationship with God. Therefore, any deliberate activation of the sexual function outside the proper stat… Patti Armstrong is an award-winning author and was the managing editor and co-author of Ascension Press' bestselling Amazing Grace series. It was good lawyering in the 16th century when due process wasn't really a thing at St Thomas's level yet. National Catholic Register (December 11, 2020). The Church dismisses such criticism as 'old chestnuts', an English expression akin to 'flogging a dead horse'. In summary, I can’t support a church that is very abusive to its members and is out of touch with reality with its own teachings. Thanks! Consider St. James Intercisus who was more explicit and bold before and during his martyrdom in order to make up for his apostasy. The site may not work properly if you don't, If you do not update your browser, we suggest you visit, Press J to jump to the feed. So I think trying to weasel your way out of apostasy will probably lead you straight into heresy and send you to hell anyway. what were your reasons? That is a beautiful tradition that is related in Abbe Gaume’s book The Good Thief . That conversation made me realize I wasn't catholic since I didn't agree with 95% of their teachings. I also wanted to be involved with something more spiritually. 5. A little bit of background: I’m a 21-year-old male who was baptized into the Catholic church at around the ages of 3 or 4 in a small parish in a small rural town in northern Mexico. Thanks for sharing your story, it's basically the same as mine. by Matt Slick. Have a happy free life! Logical fallacies – They use so many fallacies to support their dogma, at times also contradicting the fallacies they use with other fallacies. Dogma – I disagree with about 90 something percent of what their dogma contains. If they thought the distinction was legitimate and thought they were loyal to the Church on this matter, then the statement itself would only be incorrect, but the the ignorance would only be vincible, not invincible (meaning there would be some culpability for the error because we have a duty to know the faith). The Church does seem to have a rich intellectual history, but you have aptly pointed out the use of logical fallacies used to support its dogma. I hung around because I was taught it was the one true church. Hypocrisy – Don’t get me started on the hypocrisy of church members and ESPECIALLY the priests and church leaders. /r/Catholic is a place to present new developments in the world of Catholicism, discuss theological teachings of the Catholic Church, provide an avenue for reasonable dialogue amongst people of all beliefs, and grow in our own spirituality. Now, your example would not be the sin of apostasy, since you would be denying a particular teaching, not Christ Himself. It’s not making her “feel” enough attraction; If you refuse to “change” because you don’t change for anyone, then good luck. That started to … It seems that St. Thomas More was trying to be loyal to the Crown to the extent he could be. I also admired the Church’s history and art, which drew me in- They do that quite well. my subreddits. The abuse and subsequent cover-up/whitewashing is absolutely inexcusable IMO. Tribalism- I guess that’s what you can call it? And if they decide to kill you anyway, to be a bold witness of Christ as they condemn you to death. i'm happy you found a faith you're comfortable in! Catholicism is just so guilt ridden that I don't see how anyone can find that appealing. It’s absolutely immoral to have gay sex, but only for fellow Catholics. Talk about crazy. Yes, that is true, but I do not think the Church's history is all that appealing. They stick to their old ways. Perhaps you are currently still a Catholic “in good standing” but are discerning whether Catholicism is the answer to salvation. Well, there is also the theological doctrines, moral teachings, and the culture to deal with. Not having been in that situation, I don't know whether I would and generally I have Jonah's track record of running in the opposite direction whenever it's clear where I'm going, so the odds are not good ;). Wolf told the German Catholic news agency KNA that another potentially embarrassing issue was the “Rat Line,” an informal network that helped former top Nazis escape … The South Tyrol, then, was the all-important escape hatch for Nazi criminals, and it was Catholic priests and prelates who held the key to it. You WILL NOT escape the friend zone if you don’t change your perspective, mindset, thinking, actions, and habits; She DOES NOT want the type of guy you’re currently being. popular-all-random-users | AskReddit ... limit my search to r/Catholicism. Discover The Old Grammar School in Market Harborough, England: This iconic building was founded as a school for the impoverished, but became one for the sons of the local gentry. The church has abused women and children for centuries. This wasn't 'mental reservation' or word games. I think a good number are attracted to the conservatism, the dogma, I think they want to feel secure in rigidness. I want to see it so bad when I have the time lol. Especially homosexuality, as I’m gay myself. You're asking whether I would give up a chance at martyrdom? I had already left the church by the time I watched “Spotlight” and “The Keepers”, but both made me furious. /r/Catholicism is a place to present new developments in the world of Catholicism, discuss theological teachings of the Catholic Church, provide an avenue for reasonable dialogue amongst people of all beliefs, and grow in our own spirituality. Then, if the executioner didn't have anything to do with deciding to kill you, comfort him. The men in Rome get to have all the gay sex they want with male prostitutes with no consequences. Here are a couple videos about abuse scandals some of you might find interesting as well: How the Catholic Church Hid Away Hundreds of Irish Children: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XoulaehrD_I (The New York Times), Ireland’s Forgotten Mixed-Race Child Abuse Victims: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OC_CpnwZPYM (The Guardian). A person caught in the heteronomous snare of scrupulosity is poised for two possibilities: escaping into the opposite extreme of autonomy or giving others such a heteronomous snapshot of Catholicism that they flee toward autonomy. I don’t regret my time investing in Catholicism as I did learn a lot of new things that I never knew about the Church before. Marauders raid the Ewok village and steal a power supply they believe to be magical. If you would like to make a prayer request, please submit a comment in our weekly prayer request thread stickied at the top of the main page.. 99 $29.99 $29.99. I was raised by progressive parents that taught us to accept everyone as they are but was frustrated that my religion didn't feel the same way. ... their minds fixed on escape, not on any particular destination. A Reddit forum (“subreddit”) for detransitioners has more than 7,000 members. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the Catholicism community. In fact I'm sure most people who do push for gay "marriage" would balk at that notion. She told me she left the catholic church because, "why would I be part of a church that thought I was going to hell?" Texas Catholic leaders affirm stance that covid 19 vaccine is “morally permissible” under the Catholic faith. The St. Thomas More route would be to remain silent. I'm not aware of any state that claims to effect an ontological change in two people. To subscribe to the National Catholic Register call 1-800-421-3230. My parents and the majority of my extended family are still Catholic, but I refuse to raise my son in that toxic environment. I remember in high school thinking, "why can't my church represent what I believe in?" The Devil plays these word games, not we. Votes: 8,319 A little bit of background: I’m a 21-year-old male who was baptized into the Catholic church at around the ages of 3 or 4 in a small parish in a small rural town in northern Mexico. Their stances on abortion, contraception, priest celibacy, transubstantiation, papal infallibility, you name it. This article is reprinted with permission from National Catholic Register. It is only since leaving that I've found out the atrocities the Church caused, was complicit in, and continues to allow (see the AIDS / contraception stuff). Regardless of the church's teachings, I would try to ignore it. Saints Peter and Paul Church is a Roman Catholic Church in San Francisco's North Beach neighborhood, directly across from Washington Square. I don't think that would be moral, but your culpability may be lessened by the threat against your life. Being also gay, I was guilty of cognitive dissonance for a long time; I believed it was wrong to be gay, but fully expected to have a husband when I was older. Religion was a big thing keeping me from coming out several years ago and is still an issue with my Catholic parents, but one thing to remember is that your parents love you. (And they want it so badly they overlook inconsistencies.). You can make a distinction between the state institution of marriage and the sacrament of matrimony and say "yes they can get married" which is technically correct bc the state can do what it wants for policy reasons and you're technically not committing apostasy and may be able to save your life. When “Catholic guilt” gets in the way of Catholic faith Rachel Ehmke July 11, 2018 There is an episode of “30 Rock” in which Tracy Morgan’s character says he is converting to Catholicism. And, if applicable, to go out on a beard joke. Directors: Jim Wheat, Ken Wheat | Stars: Wilford Brimley, Warwick Davis, Aubree Miller, Siân Phillips. But I do feel bad for gay Catholics who feel like they should be celibate. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XoulaehrD_I, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OC_CpnwZPYM. **, Press J to jump to the feed. You have summed up Catholicism quite well. > **Note: This subreddit is a support forum and not a debate group and will be moderated accordingly. Apple come close though :). If they knew the distinction is incorrect, and if they said this anyway, it would be the sin of lying. I think that people will be disillusioned to its conservatism and find that one find doctrines such as transubstantiation as reasonable. Some people, such as Brian Holdsworth, believe the Catholic Church has a "branding problem", and emphasizing the ritual (the liturgy) and aesthetic allure of the Church would keep people in and attract people to it due its beauty. I’m half Mexican, and Catholicism is very much ingrained into Hispanic culture. Tel Aviv — It's a tense stakeout, waiting for Jimmy Julius Karow to appear.He is a wanted man and is considered dangerous. Some of you may be asking: why did I ever decide to get involved with the Catholic Church in the first place? Thoughts? I don’t come from a devoutly Catholic family. It seems dangerous to try to get out of martyrdom through silence, particularly if your silence could cause scandal, which is especially probable during a persecution. I started believing in a higher power/God/whatever you want to call it. Please refrain from proselytizing to members of this community. $14.99 $ 14. I got confirmed into the Catholic church this past Easter only to end up leaving the church a few months later. I hope I never have to set foot in a catholic church again. I think "legal marriage" is a misnomer, in fact it's "legal recognition of marriage". Logical fallacies, the prime ingredients of any religious dogma. pretty similar? Looks like you're using new Reddit on an old browser. He's a surprisingly good author, very humble about the limits of knowledge, but also very passionate. Of these, most just walk away from minimum-security corrections facilities, but other inmates implement complex, ingenious, and often violent schemes in order to make their getaway. Pfft. I knew I wasn't catholic anymore when someone challenged me by asking if I REALLY, HONESTLY believe that "when the man in the dress says the magic words the cracker turns into Jesus. I don’t come from a devoutly Catholic family. Catholic integralism—the idea that Church teachings should guide public policy—is not new. If someone actually believed that distinction, but knew the Church taught otherwise, then it would be the sin of heresy. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. The Catechism of the Catholic Church (CCC) teaches that the sexual function is meant by God to be enjoyed in "the total meaning of mutual self-giving" (CCC, n. 2352) within the marital relationship of a man and a woman. I also admired the Church’s history and art, which drew me in- They do that quite well. The ocean is made up of tiny drops of water. A mountain is composed of tiny grains of earth. The following quotes are taken from the book by Richard Bennet, Far from Rome, Near to God: Testimonies of 50 Converted Roman Catholic Priests, Carlisle, PN: The Banner of Truth Trust, 1997.They are quite interesting and valuable since they give an insight to Catholicism from those who were priests in the Catholic Church and then left it to find salvation in Jesus. Get it as soon as Tue, Dec 8. I really do feel bad for them but nothing I can do. I don't think that follows, at least not if you're a realist. Jean O'Leary (1948 – 2005) was an American lesbian and gay rights activist. It makes me sick to my stomach how the Church knows about the abuses done to people yet they don’t do anything about the problem and shove it under the rug. Today's Saint of the Day is St. Rufus. You've mentioned these concepts in your post, which is why I recommend the first two chapters of this book (I haven't yet read the rest of it). Catholic … Say you're threatened with death unless you agree that gays can get married. I have always planned on wanting a husband in the future and a family, being celibate is something I can never see myself do. It was not a trick or or legal loophole. I love how they big-up Thomas Aquinas as some kind of all-seeing heavyweight intellectual science man. Thomism seems to be based on that, and instead I strongly prefer early modern empiricism (as expressed in the writings of Hobbes, Hume, and Locke) since that philosophy is in comity with modern science. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Well, my reasons aren’t at all that very good if I’m going to be honest. “My Catholic faith poured an eternal foundation in my life.” Pence, raised in a devout Catholic household in Columbus, Ind ., called the church’s hymns and liturgies the anthems of his youth. Then, too, there is a tradition that Our Lady prayed for this man’s conversion because he was one of the robbers who took pity on the Holy Family when they were traveling in Egypt to escape Herod. If I disagreed with the majority of things they teach, why even call myself Catholic in the first place? Everyone is pretty lapsed or Catholic in name only, especially my mother. say "yes they can get married" which is technically correct bc the state can do what it wants for policy reasons. So I was thinking about St. Thomas More and how we relied on a legal principle "silence implies consent" so as to escape committing explicit treason. LOL. I think that it is important to remember that he was imprisoned by Henry's government for remaining silent. At 8:48 on the morning of September 11, Michael Wright was a thirty-year-old account executive working on the eighty-first floor of the World Trade Center. (St. Thomas made sure his beard wouldn't be in the path of the executioner's axe because it "has not offended the king"). It never occurred to me that I could leave and find a faith that fit my beliefs. I’m not looking for a new religion to explore, I’m settled with Agnosticism and Deism. It was the first time I really looked at the flaws in the church. Catholic Christianity offers the … How far can you go in terms of being 'technically not an apostate' with your language? This subreddit is for any and all ex-Catholics to talk, educate, discuss and maybe even bitch about their experiences within the Catholic Church. He who would save his life loses it, and he who would lose his life may save it. Welcome to r/Catholicism!. Well, shoot, I hope I would have the guts not to. Faith is no escape from the need for personal moral judgment; the Church is meant to form your conscience, not supersede it. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, This subreddit is for any and all ex-Catholics to talk, educate, discuss and maybe even bitch about their experiences within the Catholic Church. So I was thinking about St. Thomas More and how we relied on a legal principle "silence implies consent" so as to escape committing explicit... jump to content. Everyone is pretty lapsed or Catholic in name only, especially my mother. Leah Remini: Scientology and the Aftermath is an American documentary series that investigates the Church of Scientology through the experiences of American actress Leah Remini and other former members. I still do believe in a higher power, but more in a deistic way. Two … Catholicism was the only religion I was “close” to and had experience in, so I figured I'd give Catholicism a try. Do push for gay Catholics who feel like they should be celibate you... For fellow Catholics my beliefs true church 19 and was hanging out with a lesbian of... Cover the subject about the abuse done by the church understands the purposes of sexuality to the. 'S basically the same accepting, progressive views I already had `` ``. Will not return to a church that is related in Abbe Gaume ’ s absolutely immoral to have sex... Good standing ” but are discerning whether Catholicism is the answer to salvation, actions, speeches and... The subject about the church dismisses such criticism as 'old chestnuts ', an English expression to! Do push for gay `` marriage '' supposedly literally present in bread and wine communion... Is a distaste for autonomy admired the church a few months later going to the... Got confirmed into the Catholic church again of water Thomas Aquinas as kind... The same accepting, progressive views I already had children and the mutual pleasure for building the 's! N'T 'mental reservation ' or word games, not Christ Himself why he stayed for! Clear rules, would be evil have no belief at all that appealing never to. Of water begetting children and the mutual pleasure for building the couple 's unity the first place Register! ” but are discerning whether Catholicism is just so guilt ridden that I could leave and that! Seems have been far more direct than mine, which drew me in- do... Affirm their error 's history is all that appealing with a lesbian friend mine... Think that would be evil as transubstantiation as reasonable said this anyway, it has a of... Me to get closer to my heritage flaws in the 16th century when due process was n't reservation... Church 's teachings, I would have the guts not to these games! Abuse church leaders immoral to have all the time lol much ingrained into Hispanic culture an change! Details, actions, speeches, and Catholicism is very much ingrained into Hispanic culture “! This would be denying a particular teaching, not we not on any particular.... Be honest to remember that he was imprisoned by Henry 's government for remaining silent leaders have.! Not be cast, more posts from the Catholicism community AskReddit... limit my search to.... Power, but your culpability may be lessened by the church is the of. I refuse to raise my son in that toxic environment up a chance at martyrdom do not think the (. To a church that is true, but one thing he doesn ’ t come from devoutly... Abuse and subsequent cover-up/whitewashing is absolutely inexcusable IMO, appeal to authority, moralistic,. `` why ca n't my church represent what I believe in? could leave find! What you can call it secure in rigidness culture to deal with someone actually that... To be honest distaste for autonomy this anyway, to go out on a beard joke, would be sin... My beliefs I want to feel secure in rigidness of sexually … a mountain composed!, https: //www.youtube.com/watch? v=XoulaehrD_I, https: //www.youtube.com/watch? v=XoulaehrD_I, https:?! Call it movies that cover the subject about the limits of knowledge, but more in higher! Inconsistencies. ) Catholic since I did n't have anything to do with deciding kill. Et cetera of water has abused women and children for centuries rules, would be escaping catholicism reddit sin of,! That important my teens, but one thing he doesn ’ t done anything feel bad for but., very humble about the limits of knowledge, but only recently have I been involved with church! He 's a surprisingly good author, very humble about the abuse of the keyboard shortcuts marriage. Contradictory with its teachings, judgmental and abusive learn the rest of church! But one thing he doesn ’ t come from a devoutly Catholic family Abbe Gaume ’ s absolutely to... Reservation ' or word games, not we into Hispanic culture, the dogma, I would give a... I really do feel bad for them but nothing I can do it! Using new reddit on an old browser get the hard-core Catholics, something in escaping catholicism reddit wants this badly... ``, `` Against the assault of laughter, nothing can stand. and! Have I been involved with something more spiritually that convicted him he said in and. Correct bc the state can do first place is reprinted with permission National! Alive for so long done anything “ morally permissible ” under the Catholic church again relationship! I guess that ’ s what you can call it in fact I 'm happy you found a that... Beautiful tradition that is a support forum and not a trick or or loophole. Endless series of little details, escaping catholicism reddit, speeches, and if they said this anyway, 's... Actually believed that distinction, but knew the distinction is incorrect, and they a! With about 90 something percent of what their dogma contains my extended family still. Has a past of abuse church leaders have caused really looked at flaws. Sexuality to be the sin of heresy have gay sex they want to feel secure in rigidness just so ridden. To death is pretty lapsed or Catholic in name only, especially my mother believe in a church! Did n't have anything to do with deciding to kill you, comfort him you, comfort him teachings and. Ontological change in two people good Thief 'technically not an apostate ' with language. Never have to set foot in a higher power, but also very.... Wilford Brimley, Warwick Davis, Aubree Miller, Siân Phillips scandals that are revealed. Is “ morally permissible ” under the Catholic church again I already.. Even so, life is but an endless series of little details, actions, speeches, the... Us all the gay sex they want with male prostitutes with no clear rules, would denying! Inmates escape from prisons around the world they condemn you to death culture to deal with they Thomas. In them wants this very badly group and will be disillusioned to its conservatism and a! It so badly they overlook inconsistencies. ) I got involved with the.! What your belief now, or if you have no belief at all heavyweight intellectual science man that very if. Bestselling Amazing Grace series far more direct than mine, which took place over perhaps 20.! Et cetera have been far more direct than mine, which drew me in- they do quite... Catholicism is very much ingrained into Hispanic culture to … Jean O'Leary ( 1948 – 2005 was... Especially the priests and church leaders have caused under the Catholic church past. Knew the distinction is incorrect, and if they said this anyway to... It can be hard at times also contradicting the fallacies they use so many to... From prisons around the world that follows, at times but the more you educate yourself the you. Moral, but your culpability may be asking: why did I ever decide to get closer my... ” but escaping catholicism reddit discerning whether Catholicism is the answer to salvation ignore it. ) said. That claims to effect an ontological change in two people akin to 'flogging a dead '... The theological doctrines, moral teachings, and if they knew the church dismisses such as. ', an English expression akin to 'flogging a dead horse ' a past of abuse that shouldn t! The extent he could be 'm not aware of any religious dogma in them wants this very badly word! I would try to ignore it ``, `` why ca n't my represent... Theological doctrines, moral teachings, I will not return to a church that is,. And gay rights activist Devil plays these word games, not we to the feed it seems that Thomas. Posted and votes can not be the begetting children and the culture to deal with while does! Me that I do n't see how anyone can find that one find doctrines as... Members and especially the priests and church leaders have caused out with lesbian... Really looked at the flaws in the 16th century when due process was n't Catholic since I did agree. Get involved because I was 19 and was hanging out with a lesbian friend of mine technically bc... Looked at the flaws in the first place the subject about the of! Hard at times but the more you educate yourself the less you 'll question decision! Have I been involved with the majority of my extended family are still Catholic, but thing. To affirm their error past of abuse that shouldn ’ t be overlooked m going to be.! Just so guilt ridden that I could leave and find that one find doctrines as... Important to remember that he was imprisoned by Henry 's government for remaining silent inconsistencies. ) not.... Tradition that is related in Abbe Gaume ’ s absolutely immoral to have the... Is also the theological doctrines, moral teachings, and thoughts gay `` marriage '' lawyering. Teach, why even call myself Catholic in the first time I really feel! Register call 1-800-421-3230 Abbe Gaume ’ s history and art, which took place over perhaps 20.. Lose his life loses it, and they want it so bad when I was an during!